It is not obvious what the "European Society of Medicine" is. It might be a creation of the alleged predatory publisher Knowledge Enterprises, Inc. (KEI).
BEST COMMENTS RECEIVED
Financial complaints
- January 26, 2021: Seeing that COVID was going to keep the border closed ... , I wrote Dr. Osman and asked for my $849 USD back. Still asking. He asked me to present virtually and I'm not interested. Still waiting for my money.
- May 10, 2021: Unfortunately I paid $271.00. I then got an email saying that the bank had cancelled my payment and asking me to repay. ... I checked with the bank. There was no cancellation of payment. Unfortunately my 271 is gone. ... I should have been smarter.
- July 16, 2021: [I] contracted AMEX to dispute the registration charge. Within minutes, I got a response from AMEX: "We're writing to let you know that, as a result of our investigation, we've credited your account for $699.00, which will appear on your next statement." Clearly, AMEX is aware of the scam!
Inappropriate solicitations
- November 30, 2020: The first giveaway is that I AM NOT in radiology nor general medicine, then the misspelled email of “Dr Osman” but also that when trying the reply address what came up was not a European society of medicine email address but jm4y-kei@in.frontapp.com ...
- January 17, 2021: Reports an invitation soliciting "joining the Pathology session." His or her specialty? Speech-language pathology.
- February 5, 2021: The funniest thing is that he invited me to talk about a paper that I published 8 years ago!
- February 11, 2021: I work in a very specialized, non medical field .... Its such an inappropriate request to present at a general medical conference.
- April 25, 2021: "I am a veterinarian btw, so maybe he should do his homework before sending emails out like candy flying out of a pez dispenser." (In response to the request for a talk in the "core session" on physiology from the author of the "paper from a while ago [that] was particularly interesting for [Dr. Osman]: 'Canine Cognitive Dysfunction: Pathophysiology.'" )
- April 29, 2021: Reports an invitation from the eclectic Dr. Osman for a presentation in a "core session" on "Radiology" based on the "particularly interesting" paper on "In Trauma-Exposed Individuals" even though the author is "not in radiology" and the paper obviously "has a longer name than 'In Trauma-Exposed Individuals.'"
Oblivious responses
- January 2, 2021: A recipient of the email sent "Dr. Osman" an e-mail complaining about the "fishing technique for getting money with a fake meeting." Unperturbed, Dr. Osman replied, "I understand. Might a student or colleague be available instead?"
- February 8, 2021: "He refused to be deterred when I pointed out that my paper to which he referred so flatteringly had been published six years previously, and I had done no further work on the cohort since then - IMO, people attended conferences to learn new information, not dusty old stuff. Also, I could not see how my subject matter, even if updated, would fit into any of the conference sessions."
No responses
- February 1, 2021: I asked about [Dr. Osman's] own field of research and publications. Never got an answer. SILENCE
- July 16, 2021: I was contacted in April ... . I fell for it and registered. Then when I tried to access the conference website from a link within "Dr. Osman"'s original solicitation email, it got flagged by my university's cyber-traffic watchdog as a fraudulent site.[But a] conference site ... had a program with the session in which I was supposed to present, the title I had provided for my presentation, and even photo of me! Confused, I decided to contact the conference organizers through their legit-looking website to get clarification. I did it 3 times, and got no response.
No such place
- February 9, 2021: I happen to live in Geneva Switzerland. I decided that the easiest way to find out ... was to just go by rue le corbusier 12. [T]here was no sign, no way to ring and not even a letterbox of any european organisation of anything that could be found there.
- July 26, 2021: [C]hecking ... 12, Rue le Corbuisier, it seems the people at 'ESM' have misspelled the name of this famous architect, as no such street exists in Genève. But at 12, Rue Le-Corbusier (without the "i"), there are at least two ophtalmologists. Link: https://www.local.ch/fr/q/rue-le-corbusier-12-1208-geneve.
Incompetent conferences
- November 10, 2021: [The hotel] inform[ed] me that a congress is indeed scheduled by ESMED in their Waterfront hall, but they also received complaints from several (upcoming) hotel guests that it was badly organised and they believed it to be a scam.
- November 12, 2021: ... Dr Osman ... invited my contribution to a special section on colorectal cancer. I decided to participate only online and am watching on YouTube ... right now. [B]y far the worst meeting I have ever attended: From 5 parallel sessions only one is transmitted on YouTube; transmission is a simple camera located in the room and slides are not projected to the computer screen; the audio quality os terrible ... ; the communication of program changes did not work and there is no updated program available online; the special session on colorectal cancer does not exist, after all.
Other peculiarities
- January 20, 2021: It is strange that their web-page does not contain the history of this society and membership link does not work.
- September 7, 2021: I have discovered that the e-mails M. Osman sends inviting participation ... originate from Pakistan, either Karachi or Lahore.
- From: Organizing Committee [office@eusocietyofmedicine.org]
To: David H. Kaye
Sent: Mon, Nov 26, 2021, at 10:25 AM
Subject: genetics and "The design of 'the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation'"
I hope all is well. Did you get a chance to think about participating in the Genetics session?
Sincerely,
Organizing Committee
European Society of Medicine
2022 ESMED General Assembly - From: Organizing Committee [office@eusocietyofmedicine.org]
To: David H. Kaye
Sent: Mon, Nov 22, 2021, at 11:25 AM
Subject: genetics and "The design of 'the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation'"
Dear Dr. David H. Kaye,
Your genetics work recently caught my attention and I wanted to get in contact with you. Genetics is one of the core sessions I am planning for European Society of Medicine's General Assembly next year. I think your work could fit well within the session, maybe as a presentation related to your article "The design of 'the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation'".
The assembly is August 4-6.
May we discuss this idea?
Sincerely,
Organizing Committee
European Society of Medicine
2022 ESMED General Assembly
Our mission: To advance medicine, through knowledge and innovation.
Please think of the environment before printing this message. This message may contain confidential or copyright content. This message is a B2B communication. If you have received this message by error or want to remove your data from the system please reply or write to Rue le Corbuisier#12, 1208 Geneva Switzerland. Copyright 2021. All rights reserved. - From: Congress Committee [office@eu.esmedonline.org]
To: David H. Kaye
Sent: Wed, Aug 4, 2021, at 3:57 PM
Subject: genetics and "The design of 'the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation'"
I hope all is well. Did you get a chance to think about participating in the Genetics session?
M. Osman, M.D.
ESMED Congress 2021 -
From: Congress Committee [office@eu.esmedonline.org]
To:David H. Kaye
Sent: Sun, Jul 18, 2021, at 12:02 PM
Subject: genetics and "The design of 'the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation'"
Dear Dr. David H. Kaye,
I was hoping to get in contact with you regarding genetics work. I am organizing a session on Genetics to be part of the European Society of Medicine's annual congress this November and I thought that your work could fit well into the session, perhaps as a presentation loosely related to your paper "The design of 'the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation'".
The congress is November 11-13 in Vienna Austria. There is also an option to participate virtually.
May we discuss this idea further?
Best Regards,

Please think of the environment before printing this email. This message may contain confidential and/or copyright material. This message is a B2B communication. If you have received this message by error or wish to remove your data from the system please reply or write to Rue le Corbuisier#12, 1208 Geneva Switzerland. Copyright 2021. All rights reserved. -
From: M. Osman, M.D. [osman@med.esmed.org]
Date: Wed, Mar 31, 2021, at 6:37 AM
Subject: Re: Would like to discuss The design of “the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation”
Dear Dr. David H. Kaye,
Were you interested in discussing how your work might fit into the Genetics session?
The congress is November 11-13 in Vienna, as well as online. I would be happy to send more details or answer any questions you may have.
Best Regards,
M. Osman, M.D. -
From: M. Osman, M.D. [osman@med.esmed.org]
Date: Mon, Mar 22, 2021, at 10:50 AM
Sat, Mar 20, 2021
Subject: would like to discuss The design of “the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation”
Dear Dr. David H. Kaye,
I am hoping we can have a discussion about your Genetics work. Your paper from a while ago was particularly interesting for me: "The design of "the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation"".
Genetics is one of the core sessions I am planning for The European Society of Medicine's annual congress this November. I was thinking that your work would fit well into the session and that you might consider coming to Vienna to give a talk. Alternatively it could be an online presentation.
Can we discuss this idea?
Best Regards,
M. Osman, M.D.
European Society of Medicine
ESMED Congress 2021
Please do not print this email unless it is absolutely necessary. Every time you don't print an email, you are helping the environment. This email a B2B communication. If you have received this email in error or would like to remove your data from our system please reply, or contact us at Rue le Corbusier 12 Geneva, 1208, Switzerland. -
From: M. Osman, M.D. [osman@eu.europeansoicietyofmedicine.org]
Date: Thursday, Nov. 26, 2020, 6:09:52 AM EST
Subject: The design of 'the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation'
Dear Dr. David H. Kaye,
I am hoping to talk to you about your genetics work. I enjoyed reading your article "The design of 'the first experimental study exploring DNA interpretation'" and I was thinking that your work would be interesting to include in the Genetics session of our General Assembly next year.
I am on the organizing committee and am working on filling a few remaining speaker slots. The meeting is both in person and online.
May we discuss this further?
Best Regards,
M. Osman, M.D.
European Society of Medicine
ESMED General Assembly

